Reflection On Day 3 Of Pakistan A V England

Richie Benaud once said that the hallmark of a great captain is the ability to convince his team mates that he is able to make a crucial decision that will turn the game. With six consecutive series wins, Vaughn had that ability. Today's six wicket defeat at the hands of Pakistan A suggests that Trescothick does not.

On the positive side, Flintoff took three wickets, leaving Pietersen and either Bell or Vaughn as the only England players, who are likely to play in the first Test, still struggling for form.

The actual result is insignificant compared to the forthcoming Test matches, but the contrast between England's inspired comeback against the Patron's XI and their captulation against Pakistan A serves to undermine Trescothick's captaincy.